The Disappearances of Madelin Tomlin, Mercedes Toliver, and Destinee Bruce
Lost Girls - A podcast by Deep Dark Secrets
In this haunting episode of The Lost Girls, hosts Amy Smith and LaDonna Humphrey take listeners deep into the heart of small-town Arkansas, where safety is supposed to be a way of life — yet three young women have vanished without a trace.
Madelin Tomlin (Hope, AR – 2015), Mercedes Toliver (Prescott, AR – 2016), and Destinee Bruce (Hope, AR – 2025) are names that echo through the quiet streets of two close-knit towns now united by tragedy and unanswered questions.
LaDonna and Amy explore the unnerving parallels between these cases — three women, all young and loved, missing within an 18-mile radius. Each disappearance is different, but all share one chilling commonality: silence.
In places where “things like that don’t happen,” these women’s disappearances demand attention — and action. Their stories remind us that justice delayed is not justice denied, and that every girl deserves justice.
Sources & Acknowledgments
We are deeply grateful to the following for information used in this episode:
The Charley Project – case summaries and historical records
NamUs (National Missing and Unidentified Persons System) – official case entries and identifiers
News Archives
If you are a family member with updates or corrections, please contact us so we can keep these stories accurate and current.
