The Protectability of Short Phrases (Archive)

While iconic catchphrases from TV and film can hold significant equity, protection of them can be spotty. Scott Hervey and Tara Sattler talk about the protectability of short phrases on this archive episode of The Briefing. Watch this episode on the Weintraub YouTube channel here.   Show Notes: Scott: “Show me the money.” “Who are you going to call?” “Go ahead, make my day.” These are a few iconic phrases with significant equity, but protection of catchphrases like these is spotty. We're going to talk about the protectability of short phrases on this next installment of The Briefing by Weintraub Tobin. I'm Scott Hervey from Weintraub Tobin, and I'm joined today by my partner, Tara Sattler. Tara, thank you for joining us. Tara: Thanks for having me, Scott. Glad to be here. Scott: So, Tara, we deal with this quite a bit. Iconic short phrases that come up usually in script search reports. Now, these phrases are worth their weight in gold, and the creators of these short phrases would probably like to prevent others from using those phrases under any circumstances. But that's not always the case. Tara: Yeah, you're right, Scott. So let's first talk about quoting a short phrase in another first creative work, such as in a book, TV show, movie, or song. In order for the author of the short phrase to prevent it from being quoted in such a manner, that short phrase would have to be protectable under copyright law, and that isn't the case. Scott: That's right. Short phrases are not protectable under U.S. copyright law. According to a copyright office circular, short phrases such as slogans are unprotectable because they contain an insufficient amount of authorship, no matter how creative or catchy they may be. The copyright office will not register short phrases, even if they're novel, distinctive, or lend themselves to a play on words. Tara: And if a work is not protectable under copyright, then it cannot be the subject of a copyright infringement claim. But that doesn't mean that all uses of a third party's short phrase are always okay. Scott: That's right. While the quotation of a short phrase in books or in movies may not be actionable, the use of let's get ready to rumble in connection with the sale of goods or services could certainly bring a lawsuit. Tara: It likely would. Michael Buffer, the well-known wrestling and boxing announcer, owns a registered trademark for "let's get ready to rumble" and has been quite active in policing its use. Scott: He's been very active in policing its use. Trademark protection is the best form of IP protection for such short phrases. Short phrases are very well suited for trademark protection as long as such phrase is distinctive and they're used in connection with goods or services. Tara: Just do it is a great example of a short phrase that became a well-known trademark. But what about a quote from a movie? Scott: Well, if it's a quote like ET phone home, that could be protectable for merchandise but not likely for the movie itself. Tara: Yeah, that's right. And the same applies to may the force be with you. Scott: The problem that one may encounter is when is a short phrase not a short phrase? Right. When does it become longer material such that there's a sufficient amount of authorship and thus protectable under copyright law? I like to think that if it's more than a sentence or two,